DeepSmith

Nov 26 · AEO & AI Visibility

19 min read

AI Reputation Management: What It Is and Who Should Own It

Avinash Saurabh
Avinash Saurabh · CO-Founder & CEO
A monochrome shield outline at the center of a network of answer cards and connecting lines, with the cover line Who Owns AI Reputation across it.

AI reputation management is the work of keeping the public information that AI systems may draw on about your organization accurate, consistent, and fairly represented in the answers they generate, while accepting that you can't dictate what those answers say. If you've been asked who at your company is responsible for how ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity describes you, this is the idea behind that question, and it's a fair one to be unsure about. Most teams haven't settled it yet. This guide explains what AI reputation management covers, how the answers come together, why it matters now, and which team should be accountable for it.

It helps to say up front what this piece is and isn't. It's a definition and an ownership decision. It doesn't walk you through setting up monitoring, and it doesn't give you an escalation playbook for a bad answer. Those come later, once you know what you're managing and who's managing it.

What is AI reputation management?

AI reputation is the picture of your organization that generative AI tools present when someone asks about you, your products, your leaders, or your category. AI reputation management is the cross-functional effort to make that picture as accurate and fair as the public record allows. It's cross-functional because the facts an AI answer pulls together usually come from several places in the company, not one.

The idea is wider than whether your name shows up, because reputation in AI answers includes what is said as well as whether you're named. A few things tend to matter, and it's useful to keep them separate in your head:

  • Visibility: whether you appear at all in the answers that are relevant to you.
  • Accuracy: whether the claims about your organization, products, people, and actions are correct and current.
  • Narrative and framing: what the answer chooses to emphasize, leave out, or treat as important.
  • Source quality: which sources back up the answer, and whether those sources really support what the answer says about you.
  • Sentiment and recommendation: whether you're described or recommended positively, neutrally, or negatively, and in what context.
  • Consistency: whether the picture changes much from one prompt, platform, or day to the next.

These are editorial categories, not an official measurement standard. A contributor to the Institute for Public Relations proposed a similar list in 2026 that includes visibility, factual accuracy, authority, citation quality, consistency, narrative alignment, and recommendation strength. It's a reasonable way to think about the problem, but nobody has validated it as an industry framework, so treat it as a starting vocabulary rather than a rulebook.

Mentions and citations are different things

One place people get tangled is the difference between a mention and a citation. A mention means the answer names your brand. A citation means the answer shows a source page as support. You can have one without the other. An answer might name you without linking to any page, and an answer might cite a page of yours while describing you in a lukewarm or even unfavorable way. A citation doesn't tell you the brand is recommended, and a mention doesn't tell you the facts are right. If you want a fuller look at how those numbers get produced and what they can and can't tell you, what AI brand monitoring tracks is a good companion read.

How it relates to ordinary reputation

AI reputation isn't a separate reputation sitting beside the real one. AI tools interpret and repeat information that's already out in the public environment, and they don't create your conduct or your standing from nothing. The material an answer might touch includes your company and product pages, press coverage, third-party commentary, public records, and other written sources. That's a practical way to picture the landscape, not a claim that every model uses or weighs the same sources in the same way. So the work is mostly about the same things reputation work has always been about, with one new place where the result shows up.

How do AI answers form a picture of your brand?

AI answers synthesize information instead of handing back a stable ranked list of links, and that changes what "managing" a result can mean. A search results page shows you ten blue links in an order. An AI answer reads, combines, and restates, and different tools do that in different ways.

Some of these experiences use web retrieval. OpenAI says ChatGPT search can draw on third-party search providers and on content supplied by partners. Google describes something it calls query fan-out in AI Overviews and AI Mode, where related searches can be used to build a response. Google also says those features may use different models and techniques, so the responses and the links shown can vary.

That variation is worth holding onto. You shouldn't assume every model always searches the live web, or that every model draws on the same sources, or that the same question gets the same reply each time. Context matters too. ChatGPT may use approximate location and, when memory is turned on, saved location information, so the answer one person sees isn't necessarily the one you see when you test it yourself. A brand's answer isn't one fixed result that every person receives in every situation.

Access is a separate matter from influence. OpenAI's documentation separates crawling used for search from other crawler uses, and its search announcement says publishers can choose to appear in ChatGPT search. Those facts are about whether your content is eligible to be found. They don't give you control over how an answer is worded, which other sources get included, or whether a particular claim gets repeated.

If you're trying to work out where you stand in all of this, it also helps to know that tools can give you different views of the same thing. There's a useful distinction between tracking your brand in AI answers and monitoring your own apps' usage, and brand visibility tracking versus internal usage monitoring lays that out so you don't end up shopping for the wrong kind of tool.

Why does AI reputation matter now?

AI answers are turning into another place where people meet your story, and some of them meet it before they ever reach your site. You don't need a dramatic claim to see why that's worth planning for. The evidence we have is modest, and it's worth reading with its limits in view.

Start with how many people are using these tools for brand research. In Edelman's 2025 Brand Trust research, 55% of respondents said they used generative AI platforms, and among those users, 91% said they used them for shopping in some way, including researching brands, comparing products, and summarizing reviews. The research covered 15,000 respondents across 15 countries, with fieldwork from April 24 to May 5, 2025. The 91% applies only to the group that used generative AI, not to everyone surveyed, so it would be wrong to say that 91% of consumers shop through AI. The study also doesn't show that an AI answer causes a purchase or changes how much someone trusts a brand. What it does support is the simpler point that AI has become part of how some people research and compare brands.

The personal stakes can be real too. In 2023, Reuters reported that Brian Hood, the mayor of Hepburn Shire in Australia, was considering legal action after ChatGPT allegedly told users that he had been imprisoned for bribery. According to the report, his lawyers said he had actually been the one who alerted authorities to the bribery and had never been charged. That story described a possible lawsuit at the time, and it doesn't tell us whether one was filed or how it ended. It's useful as an example of the kind of harm that's possible, not as evidence of how often it happens or as a legal precedent.

Answer quality is uneven

It's also worth knowing that these tools get things wrong in measurable ways. A study by the European Broadcasting Union and the BBC, published in October 2025, looked at 2,709 responses to core news questions from the free consumer versions of ChatGPT, Copilot, Perplexity, and Gemini, generated in late May and early June 2025. It found that 45% of the evaluated responses had at least one significant issue, 81% had an issue when lesser issues were counted, and 20% had significant accuracy problems.

That study was about news answers. It wasn't about answers regarding companies or products, so it isn't an error rate for brand reputation, and you shouldn't quote it that way. It does show that answer quality is fallible in a controlled test, which is a fair reason to check what's being said about you instead of assuming it's right.

Who should own AI reputation management?

One person or function should be accountable for it, and several others should contribute. The default owner we'd suggest is your senior communications, PR, or reputation lead. This is an editorial recommendation based on what reputation work is and on practitioner guidance, so it's not a settled rule across the industry, and it's worth saying plainly that real companies are doing it in different ways.

The reasoning is fairly simple. AI reputation is about public narrative and stakeholder trust across several audiences, and that's the territory communications teams already work in. PRSA describes public relations as a strategic communication process that builds mutually beneficial relationships between organizations and their publics, and it includes protecting an organization's reputation among PR responsibilities. Practitioner writing from Signal Group and from a 2026 Wiztrust article makes a similar argument for communications as the logical accountable owner. Those are professional positions, not independent proof of a best practice, but they line up with the nature of the work.

What the survey says about ownership today

If you're wondering whether your company is behind, the numbers suggest most are still working it out. Muck Rack's State of PR 2026 survey found that 73% of respondents consider generative engine optimization at least somewhat important to their PR or communications strategy. When asked who is primarily responsible for it at their organization, they answered this way:

Who is primarily responsibleShare of respondents
No one yet29%
PR and communications24%
SEO or content15%
Not sure13%
Marketing leadership11%
A dedicated AI or innovation team9%

Muck Rack surveyed 1,115 PR professionals from May 14 to June 12, 2026, and kept 971 usable responses after exclusions. It notes that some question wording changed from earlier years, that percentages may not add to 100% because of rounding or exclusions, and that year-over-year comparisons may not be valid. These are the answers of PR professionals, so they don't tell you which structure works best. What they do show is that the field hasn't converged on one owner, and that the single most common answer is that nobody owns it yet. If that's your situation, you're in the largest group.

A division of responsibility that works

Here's one way to split the work so the accountability is clear and the contributors know their part.

  • Communications, PR, or reputation: accountable for the overall narrative and the reputation standard. This team convenes the others and makes sure the organization speaks consistently across audiences.
  • Marketing and brand: contributes positioning, product descriptions, proof points, and your owned content. If you don't have a communications or reputation lead, a marketing leader is a practical accountable owner, as long as the role has the standing to bring the other teams together.
  • SEO, content, and AEO specialists: handle much of the technical and editorial execution, including how clear and easy to find your public information is. They shouldn't be treated as the sole owners of reputation just because some of the work happens in search or content.
  • Product, customer support, sales, HR, investor relations, government affairs, and subject-matter experts: check the facts in their own areas. An AI-generated description can combine information that crosses the usual department lines, so no single team sees all of it.
  • Legal and compliance: advise on sensitive claims, regulated information, privacy, and legal exposure. Their involvement doesn't replace communications ownership of the overall narrative.
  • Executive leadership: steps in when the underlying issue is material business risk, organizational conduct, or strategy, and isn't a communications problem alone.

The decision rule that follows is easy to apply. Give accountability to the existing senior role that already owns organizational reputation and stakeholder communication. Where that role doesn't exist, make marketing leadership the accountable fallback. Then name the specialist and fact-owner contributors out loud, so the work isn't split vaguely between PR, marketing, and SEO with nobody sure who decides.

It also helps to be clear about why SEO and content shouldn't hold the whole thing by default. They're essential partners, and you'll lean on them heavily for execution. But reputation involves what answers say, whether they're accurate, and how the organization is framed, and those questions reach past search into messaging, facts, and judgment calls that a search team isn't set up to make alone.

One more point on responsibility. PRSA's October 2025 ethical guidance is about how practitioners use AI, and it isn't a study of who should manage AI-generated reputation. It does support a principle that fits here, which is that AI doesn't remove professional responsibility, and human judgment should lead strategy, ethics, and reputation management. It's guidance on principle, not proof that a particular org chart works.

What can you control, and what can't you?

You can make your public information clearer, more consistent, and easier to find. You can't guarantee how an AI system will describe you, what it will retrieve or cite, or whether a correction you make will change later answers. Keeping that line in view saves you from promises you can't keep and from a lot of frustration.

Google's own guidance is a good guardrail against inflated claims. Its documentation says there are no additional requirements or special optimizations for AI Overviews and AI Mode beyond foundational Search practices, and that meeting the requirements doesn't guarantee Google will crawl, index, or serve a page. So if someone tells you that a certain markup or content change will guarantee a citation or a favorable answer, it's fair to be skeptical.

This is also what it really means to manage brand in ChatGPT. You aren't editing a profile page that you own. You're shaping the public record that the tool may read from, and you're checking the result from time to time. A few limits are worth remembering as you do that.

A citation isn't proof of truth

The source an answer shows may be incomplete, out of date, or may not actually support the sentence it's attached to. A citation tells you where the tool looked, not that the claim is right or that you're endorsed. When you review an answer, it's worth looking at whether the answer is accurate and what tone it takes, in addition to whether a source is present.

An unfavorable answer isn't automatically a crisis

A negative-sounding answer might reflect a plain inaccuracy, an old source, the particular wording of one prompt, or real criticism that's fair. It's not always the result of poor optimization, and more brand content won't necessarily fix it. Part of good reputation work is telling these cases apart before you react, and that's where having a clear owner pays off, since someone has to make the call.

Don't invent evidence

It can be tempting to improve how you look by seeding reviews or testimonials. The FTC's 2024 Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule addresses fake or false consumer reviews, including AI-generated ones, and it prohibits buying or procuring reviews when a business knew or should have known they were fake. That's a narrow rule about deceptive reviews, not a general rule that all AI-assisted content has to be disclosed. It's a useful reminder that the way to improve reputation in AI answers is to make the true story clearer, not to manufacture a better one.

Keep the evidence types straight

When you read about this topic, the sources carry different weight. Official engine documentation is the best source for what the platforms say about their own search and eligibility. Surveys tell you what respondents reported or believed. Practitioner articles, including the ownership arguments above, are useful but they aren't neutral experiments. It helps to keep those apart in your own notes so a survey result doesn't quietly turn into a rule.

What should you do with this?

If you take only a few things from this guide, the first is to decide who's accountable. A name on a document does more than a committee. Pick the senior reputation or communications lead, or marketing leadership if that role doesn't exist, and write down the contributors from SEO, content, product, support, legal, and the other teams that own facts.

The second is to agree on what you're looking at. The dimensions earlier in this piece, visibility, accuracy, framing, source quality, sentiment, and consistency, give your team a shared vocabulary, so a conversation about "what AI says about us" doesn't turn into several different conversations. If you'd like to know how sentiment scoring behaves and where it falls short, how AI sentiment analysis works explains the limits so you can read the numbers sensibly. Looking at how AI explains your whole category, not just your brand, can also be revealing, and category-level narratives in AI answers shows what to log.

The third is to start looking, in a small and regular way. Once someone owns the work, the practical next step is checking a fixed set of questions on a schedule so you're comparing like with like each time. Setting up AI brand monitoring in one afternoon is a manageable way to begin. When you're ready to be told about changes without checking by hand, you can set up alerts for AI mention changes that go to a named person. Deciding what counts as a real shift and what's noise matters here too, which is what alert thresholds for AI visibility covers.

For the tooling side, it's reasonable to look at what's on the market before you commit to anything. The best AI brand monitoring tools comparison covers tools that detect and alert on mentions across AI assistants. The broader AI visibility tools roundup covers tools that measure where a brand appears across AI search engines. If sentiment is your main concern, there's a separate comparison of AI brand sentiment tools too.

DeepSmith is one way to do the checking. It tracks mention rate, citation rate, share of voice, and sentiment across AI engines, and it shows which of your pages get cited, so the person who owns the work has numbers to look at. The tool isn't the owner, though. That's still a person, and the decision about who it is comes first. When you're ready to see what your own results look like, you can start a free trial and check a starter set of questions with real data.

Frequently asked questions

What is AI reputation management?

It's the work of making sure the public information AI systems may draw on about an organization is accurate, consistent, and fairly represented in generated answers, while recognizing that the organization can't dictate those answers. It covers visibility, accuracy, framing, source quality, sentiment, and consistency, not just whether your name appears.

Who should own AI reputation management?

A senior communications, PR, or reputation lead should normally be accountable. Marketing can own it in organizations without that function, while SEO and content teams and the teams responsible for the underlying facts contribute. Survey data shows the field hasn't settled on one owner, so this is a reasoned recommendation and not an industry consensus.

Is AI reputation management just SEO or GEO?

No. SEO and GEO can support discoverability and citation eligibility, but reputation also concerns what answers say, whether they're accurate, which sources support them, and how the organization is framed. Those are questions of narrative and fact as well as search.

Can a company control what ChatGPT says about its brand?

No. A company can influence how clear and available its public information is, and it can make choices about search eligibility, but it can't guarantee the wording, the source selection, or the outcome of any one answer.