DeepSmith

Nov 26 · AEO & AI Visibility

16 min read

Why Microsoft Copilot Needs Its Own Visibility Tracking, Separate From Bing

Avinash Saurabh
Avinash Saurabh · CO-Founder & CEO
Two dark panels joined by a thin line, a stacked results list on the left and a written answer with source tags on the right, behind the words Copilot Is Not Bing.

Bing rankings are useful background for Copilot, but they can't tell you whether Copilot mentions your brand, which of your pages it cites, or how it describes you in an answer. That is the short version of the copilot vs bing visibility question, and it's worth walking through because the two share a lot of plumbing, which makes it easy to assume one number covers both. If you already watch your Bing positions and wonder whether that's enough for Copilot, this guide explains why it usually isn't and what a Copilot-specific view adds. It doesn't cover setup steps, since those have their own guide.

Bing and Copilot are connected, which is why this gets confusing

It would be simpler if Copilot and Bing were two unrelated systems, but they aren't. Microsoft says Bing and Copilot share core crawling, indexing and ranking foundations, and that Copilot can use Bing search results to ground its answers. So when you do the usual work of making pages crawlable, indexed and clear, you're also doing part of the work that makes a page eligible for Copilot. That's the honest starting point for any copilot seo conversation.

An academic study points the same way. A December 2025 preprint from Peixian Zhang and colleagues, Source Coverage and Citation Bias in LLM-based vs. Traditional Search Engines, compared six LLM search experiences with Google and Bing across 55,936 queries. The authors collected U.S. trend-based queries daily from July 16 to August 10, 2025, and their Copilot analysis used Copilot in Bing. In their table of mean domain overlap, Copilot against Bing came out at 0.999, which is very high.

It helps to be careful about what that number says. It's a measure of overlap at the domain level, in one U.S. collection period in 2025, for Copilot in Bing. It doesn't mean every Copilot citation matches a Bing ranking, that the same URLs or positions are used, or that the relationship holds for every Copilot product, region and date. These products change, so treat the study as a good sign that Bing matters, not as a rule you can lean on forever.

The useful way to hold both ideas is this. Shared Bing foundations and strong domain overlap can exist right alongside a real need to measure Copilot answers separately from ordinary Bing rankings. Ranking helps explain how a page gets discovered and whether it's eligible. It doesn't show what actually appears in the answer.

A ranking and an answer are different things to measure

When someone searches in Bing, the result is a list of pages in an order. When someone asks Copilot a question, the result is a written response, and for certain information-seeking conversations Microsoft says that response is grounded in web search results and comes with hyperlinked citations. Those are two different outputs, and they need two different measurements.

A rank tells you where a page sat in a set of results. An answer-level view tells you whether your brand was named, whether one of your pages was linked as a source, which other sources were used, and what the text said about you. A rank report captures none of those things. If you'd like a wider look at why this shift affects every engine, the best AI visibility tools roundup shows what tools measure once the unit moves from a position to an answer.

Here is the difference laid out side by side.

What you want to knowBing ranking reportCopilot-level view
Where a page sits in search resultsYesNot the point
Whether the brand is named in an answerNoYes
Which exact pages are cited as sourcesNoYes
What the answer says about the brandNoYes
Which other brands or pages share the answerNoYes
How results shift by prompt wording or follow-upLimitedYes

Difference one: the question sent to Bing is not the question the user typed

This is the part most people don't expect. A person might type a long, chatty question with background and a follow-up from an earlier turn. Microsoft describes Copilot working out whether web information would help, picking out the terms where it would, and writing a short search query that it sends to Bing. That generated query is not the user's whole prompt.

Microsoft's own example makes it concrete. A request to summarize a company's financial information and business strategy in the context of a possible acquisition turns into a short query along the lines of "Fabrikam strategy Fabrikam financials". The results of that search are then used to compose or improve the response. The transparency note for individual users adds that the prompt and recent conversation history can be used to put the request in context, and that the system decides whether web grounding is needed at all.

So if you check Bing for the exact words a customer would type into Copilot, you may not be looking at the search that shaped the answer. The reverse is also true. A short grounding phrase that shows up in a report is not the user's full question, and it's a mistake to read it as one.

What to do with this: when you plan which questions to watch, write them the way people talk in a conversation, including the follow-ups, instead of only the short keyword you rank for. Then the thing you measure is closer to what a person would actually ask, which is the same idea behind tracking any Google AI Overviews prompt set.

Difference two: a citation is not a rank position

A Bing ranking measures where a page landed in a set of results. A Copilot citation measures whether a page was shown as a source in a generated answer. Microsoft's webmaster guidance says the shared foundations support eligibility, but it doesn't promise that a good ranking leads to grounding or a citation. It says content that Bing can interpret and verify, and that stands on its own, is more likely to be chosen for grounding and citations. It also says plainly that SEO does not guarantee rankings or traffic, and that GEO does not guarantee grounding or citations. You can read that in the Bing webmaster guidelines.

Microsoft's April 2025 description of Copilot Search in Bing gives a feel for how this looks on the screen. Cited sources are prominent, and a full sentence or passage can be linked to its source. That's a different kind of visibility from sitting at number three on a results page. A page can be cited without ranking first, and a page can rank well without being cited. How the answer is laid out can also vary across Copilot experiences, so it's safest not to assume every surface looks the same.

If you also care about how Google's AI answers compare, AI Overviews versus AI Mode for tracking covers the same kind of split on that side.

Difference three: the answer is built from context and several sources

Microsoft describes Copilot answers as using the prompt, recent conversation history and, when it's appropriate, search results. Its current Bing material on AI visibility describes AI-generated answers as dynamic, contextual and often put together from several sources. The consumer transparency note also reminds people that AI can make mistakes and that they should check the sources.

That has two consequences for you. First, a page can matter as a supporting source without its role showing up in any rank number. Second, your brand can be described in the generated text without being cited as a source in the same way. Those are two separate kinds of presence, and a rank report sees neither.

It's also worth saying what this does not mean. There's no good evidence here that Copilot always uses a completely separate index, always pulls different sources, or ignores Bing rank. The careful claim is smaller and easier to defend. Bing is part of the discovery and grounding picture, and a ranking on its own can't describe the answer and its visible citations.

Because answers depend on wording and context, you'll also see them change from one check to the next. Why AI answers change from run to run explains how trackers deal with that, and it's a good reason to look at patterns across many checks instead of one answer. Other engines have their own habits too, as the guides to the best ChatGPT visibility tools and the best Gemini visibility tracking tools show.

Does Copilot always search Bing?

No. Microsoft says web grounding is used when the system decides it's appropriate. Some requests need current public information and benefit from a search, and others don't, so you shouldn't assume every Copilot response triggers one.

This matters for tracking because it means some of the answers you collect will have no web sources behind them at all. If your brand shows up in one of those, there's no citation to find, and if it doesn't show up, there's no ranking that explains why. Another reason a Bing rank can't stand in for the answer.

What Bing's own AI reporting does and doesn't cover

It would be wrong to say Microsoft gives you nothing here. On February 10, 2026, Microsoft introduced the AI Performance report in Bing Webmaster Tools in public preview. Its stated coverage includes Microsoft Copilot, AI-generated summaries in Bing and select partner AI integrations. It's a real citation view, and it's useful.

The documented measures are:

  • Total Citations: how many times your content was displayed as a source in AI-generated answers during the period you pick.
  • Cited pages: the unique pages on your site that were cited, with page-level activity.
  • Average Cited Pages: the average number of unique pages shown as sources per day over the period.
  • Grounding queries: the phrases used to retrieve content that was then referenced in answers.
  • Visibility over time: how citation activity changes across the supported AI experiences.

The limits are worth knowing before you build a process on it. The data is aggregated across the supported AI experiences, so it's not a Copilot-only record, and the documentation I reviewed doesn't show a Copilot-only filter. The grounding-query rows are short phrases or grouped versions of them, not full prompts or individual answers. Microsoft also says the grounding data is sampled, that very low or infrequent citation activity may not appear, that totals can differ between views, and that the figures are meant for trends rather than exact accounting. A citation count is not a click, a visit or a conversion, and it isn't a measure of ranking, authority or importance either. The report's documentation page lays these caveats out.

What was added during 2026

Microsoft has kept adding to the report. On June 16, 2026, it announced preview features called Intents, Topics, Citation Share and Compare. Intents groups grounding queries into broad categories such as informational, commercial, navigational, learn and solve, research, creation and local. Topics groups related grounding queries into themes. Citation Share is your share of the citations shown across sites for the same grounding query, which Microsoft describes as observational and not a ranking system or a competitor scoreboard. It doesn't name competitor domains or stand for traffic share. Compare lays a previous period over the current one, such as the last 30 days against the 30 before, so you can see what changed, though not why.

On October 13, 2026, Microsoft announced a beta Topics Portfolio view. It groups a site's grounding queries into broader themes and adds approximate measures such as topic size, sites cited and distinct queries, along with opportunity queries where other sites appear and yours doesn't. Microsoft cautions that these figures are directional, that the topic grouping is AI-generated and can be imperfect, and that topics with too little activity may not appear.

Put together, this supports the argument for a separate view instead of undercutting it. Even Microsoft treats AI citations as something that needs their own report next to ordinary search data, and that report is aggregated and has real gaps. It's a good input, and you'd still want to look at the answers themselves to see how your brand is described and who else is named.

What a Copilot-specific view adds

A useful Copilot view answers questions a rank report can't. You can think of them as a short list to check against any report or tool you use:

  • Does Copilot mention the brand for the questions that matter, and how does it describe the brand?
  • Does it cite your own pages, and which exact URLs show up as sources?
  • Which of the prompts you tested produce citations, and which don't?
  • Which competing brands or pages appear in the answer or the source set instead of yours?
  • Does what you see change with the Copilot surface, the way the prompt is worded, the follow-up context or the time period?

These are the questions an editor would want answered, not a promise that every product exposes all of them. A helpful way to keep them straight is visibility in a search result versus visibility in an answer. In an answer, you can observe brand mentions, citations, which page was cited, the mix of sources and how you compare with others. A citation count alone doesn't capture sentiment or the user's full prompt, and a rank captures none of it.

If you want to see how this plays out inside one engine, how to track Microsoft Copilot visibility walks through the practical steps, and how AI Overviews tracking works shows the same idea on Google's side.

What this means for the phrases you're searching

A few of the terms people use for this are worth pinning down, because they get used loosely.

Copilot vs Bing visibility is a comparison between different outcomes, not a claim that Copilot and Bing have nothing in common. The two share infrastructure and can still show you different things.

Copilot SEO can include the familiar foundations of crawlability, indexing and clear content. Those get a page into the conversation, and eligibility is not the same as being cited.

An SEO tool for Copilot is worth judging by one thing, which is whether it actually observes Copilot answers and citations. A tool that only relabels Bing rank tracking is telling you about the ranking, not the answer. When you compare options, the best Microsoft Copilot visibility tools list shows what is on offer, and the best tools to optimize for Microsoft Copilot list covers the improvement side.

What you can safely claim, and what to avoid

If you're explaining this to a boss or a client, it's easy to overstate, so here are the lines to stay inside.

  • Don't say Copilot ignores Bing rankings or runs on a completely independent web index.
  • Don't say ranking well guarantees a Copilot mention, a citation or traffic.
  • Don't say every Copilot prompt triggers a web search.
  • Don't call a reported grounding phrase the exact prompt a user typed.
  • Don't treat a citation as a click, a visit or a conversion.
  • Don't describe Bing's AI Performance report as Copilot-only or as a full record of every answer.
  • Don't say the 2025 study proves a stable, universal link between Copilot and Bing.
  • Don't read Citation Share as a list of named competitors or as a conventional ranking.

What you can say is that Bing is part of the Copilot story, that shared foundations explain why Bing basics matter, and that generated queries, context-driven answers and visible citations explain why a rank report can't stand in for Copilot visibility.

Where this leaves you

If you're a marketing lead deciding what to add to your reporting, a sensible order is to keep your Bing fundamentals in place, turn on the AI Performance report if you haven't, and then add a regular look at actual Copilot answers for the questions your buyers ask, using an seo tool for copilot that reads answers and not only ranks. The first two tell you about eligibility and aggregated citations. The third tells you what a buyer actually sees.

For teams that want that answer-level view without building it by hand, DeepSmith tracks Microsoft Copilot as one of ten engines, with Copilot coverage on Enterprise and Custom plans, and reports mention rate, citation rate and the pages cited per prompt. If you'd like to see how the tracking side works before deciding, you can start a free trial and look at real data.

Frequently asked questions

Does Bing ranking affect Copilot visibility?

Bing is still relevant. Microsoft describes shared crawling, indexing and ranking foundations and says Copilot can use Bing web results for grounding. Ranking alone doesn't tell you whether a page is cited or a brand appears in the generated answer.

Does Copilot always search Bing?

No. Microsoft says web grounding is used when the system decides it's appropriate. Web search helps with questions that need current public information, but you shouldn't assume every response triggers one.

Are Copilot's grounding queries the same as users' prompts?

No. Microsoft says Copilot can derive a short Bing query from the user's prompt. Bing Webmaster Tools describes grounding-query rows as short phrases or grouped versions of them, not complete user questions.

Does Bing Webmaster Tools now show Copilot citations?

AI Performance includes Microsoft Copilot alongside Bing AI summaries and select partner integrations. It reports citation activity and related summaries, but the reporting is aggregated and sampled, it isn't a full log of prompts and answers, and the documentation doesn't establish a Copilot-only breakdown.