DeepSmith

Nov 26 · Tools & Comparisons

20 min read

How to Evaluate an AI Visibility Tool: Questions to Ask Before You Pay

Avinash Saurabh
Avinash Saurabh · CO-Founder & CEO
Abstract monochrome cover showing a layered scorecard panel with empty checkboxes linked to three vendor nodes behind the words Evaluate Before You Buy.

If you have a demo on the calendar with an AI visibility vendor, it helps to walk in with your own questions, because the demo will otherwise follow the vendor's script. This guide covers how to choose AI visibility provider options in eight steps, and it ends with a 100-point scorecard you can fill in during or right after each call. It's written for marketing leads who will own the budget and need to defend the choice later.

You'll need a short list of two or three vendors, a spreadsheet, and about an hour to prepare. The steps below don't ask you to run a trial or audit anyone's numbers, since those are separate jobs. They're about getting clear, written answers before you sign anything.

Step 1: Write down the decisions the data has to support

Start with what you want to do with the numbers, not with the tool. Most teams want to know which buyer questions mention their brand, which answers cite their pages, which competitors show up instead, and which content gaps are worth filling first. Write those down as plain sentences. Then pick 15 or 20 real buyer questions that cover awareness, consideration, and decision-stage searches, and mix in some that use your brand name, your product name, and your category language.

These questions are what you'll bring to every demo as you evaluate AI visibility tool options. Then ask each vendor these:

  • Can we track our own prompts, and can we label them by topic, funnel stage, market, or campaign?
  • Can we see the prompt and the full answer behind each reported result?
  • Can we tell a brand mention apart from a citation of one of our pages?
  • Can we compare ourselves with chosen competitors on the same prompt?
  • If the tool suggests prompts, how does it come up with them, and can we edit them?

You're done with this step when the vendor shows you a prompt set organized the way your team thinks, with each result tied back to the question that produced it.

Common mistake: Letting each vendor demo with its own favorite queries. Their examples will look great because they were picked to. Bring your own questions so every vendor answers the same ones.

Step 2: Pin down the engines, surfaces, markets, and schedule

An engine count on a pricing page doesn't tell you much. What matters is the exact list of products being checked and whether the ones your buyers use are in the plan you're quoted. Ask the vendor to name every engine and experience included at your tier, and to say which ones are add-ons or enterprise-only.

Pay special attention to names that sound alike. Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode are different experiences, and a vendor that says "Google" might mean one, both, or neither. Also write down the countries and languages your buyers actually search in.

Ask these:

  • Which exact engines and AI experiences are included at this tier, and which are add-ons?
  • Does "Google" mean AI Overviews, AI Mode, or both?
  • Where does each prompt run, and can a prompt be set to a country or language?
  • How often is each prompt checked, and is that the same on every engine and plan?
  • What uses up quota: a prompt, a prompt run on one engine, a prompt-country-engine combination, or a credit that weighs engines differently?
  • What happens to collection when an AI platform changes its interface, model, or access rules?

You're done when the quote or plan summary lists the engines, experiences, regions, refresh schedule, and quota unit in writing, and that list matches what your leadership expects to see.

Common mistake: Treating an engine count as a coverage promise. One vendor's plan may let you pick from a large catalog of engines but charge credits for every run, and another may cap how many models can be active at once.

This is where DeepSmith lays out its tiers plainly. Pro tracks ChatGPT, Grow adds Perplexity, Scale adds Gemini, and Enterprise covers all ten engines: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Grok, Meta AI, Microsoft Copilot, and DeepSeek. AI Visibility checks your prompts on a schedule and reports by platform. If a tool you're considering can't give you a list like that in writing, that tells you something before you've even looked at the dashboard.

Step 3: Ask how the data is collected

You don't need to audit anything here. You just need a plain-language answer to what the tool queries, what it records, and what the dashboard does not show. If a vendor can't explain that without leaning on the phrase "AI visibility," it's hard to know what you'd be paying for.

Ask these:

  • Does collection use public AI interfaces, an API, or some other method, and is it the same for every engine?
  • Is each result a point-in-time answer to the configured prompt and location, or is it modeled or averaged from other data?
  • Does the tool say anything about personalization or account state that could change an answer, and what does it not capture?
  • Is the dashboard a full record of possible answers, or a sample?
  • Is answer history kept, and for how long? Can we open the underlying answer behind a single measurement?

You're done when you can describe in one or two sentences what the tool asks, what it saves, and whether you're looking at a complete log or a sample.

For a sense of what a good answer sounds like, OtterlyAI's help pages say it reaches AI platforms through their public web interfaces, tracks public AI-generated content, runs configured prompts daily, and lets you assign a prompt to a country because answers can differ by region. That's one vendor's description, not an industry standard, so hold the next vendor to the same level of detail.

Common mistake: Assuming a dashboard shows every answer every person might get. Method, location, timing, model behavior, and sampling all shape what a tool can report. If you want to dig deeper into how the numbers are gathered, the guide to how AI visibility tools collect data goes through the main approaches. Answers also shift from one run to the next, so ask how the tool handles that, which why AI citations keep changing explains well.

Step 4: Get a definition for every metric

Two tools can both show a "visibility score" and be measuring different things. Before you compare numbers, ask each vendor to define every headline metric, its denominator, and its unit.

The three you'll see most often are related but not the same. Mention rate (sometimes called visibility) asks how often your brand appears in answers. Citation rate asks how often your pages are linked or cited. Share of voice compares your brand mentions with a defined group of other brands.

Ask these:

  • What exactly counts as a mention? Does it count once per response, or again for each repeat within an answer?
  • What counts as a citation: a linked page, a listed source, a domain mention, or something else?
  • What's in the share-of-voice denominator: every brand named, only the competitors you track, or another set?
  • Are percentages worked out across all prompts, engines, and locations, or only the subset currently selected?
  • Can we break results down by prompt, engine, competitor, and time period?
  • If sentiment is shown, how is it assigned, and can we open the answer it came from?

You're done when the vendor can give you a formula or a clear definition for each headline metric, and can show a number changing as you switch the prompt, engine, or date range.

To see why this matters, look at how Peec AI documents its metrics. Its docs define visibility as responses that mention the brand divided by total responses, times 100, and share of voice as the brand's mentions divided by all brand mentions, times 100. Those are reasonable definitions, and they show that a "share" depends entirely on what's in the denominator. Ask every vendor for theirs instead of assuming there's one shared definition. DeepSmith reports mention rate, citation rate, and share of voice, along with sentiment and the trend over time, so you can ask us the same questions.

Common mistake: Reading a citation count as proof of traffic or as a ranking. Bing's own Webmaster Tools help page separates visible citation activity from traditional rankings, clicks, and traffic. A citation means a source was shown in an answer, and nothing more than that. If any of these terms are new to you, the AEO glossary covers them.

Step 5: Look at the reports, answer history, exports, and integrations

A dashboard is nice to look at, but you'll probably need the data somewhere else too, like a slide deck, a BI tool, or a spreadsheet. Ask to see the actual table or export, and match its fields to the way your team already reports.

Ask these:

  • Can we see full answer history, with the date of each run, the prompt, the engine, and the cited URLs?
  • Can reports be filtered by prompt, engine, country, competitor, date, and page?
  • Can we export CSV or JSON, and are raw responses included or only summary charts?
  • Is API access included in the plan we'd buy, and what fields, history, rate limits, and usage costs apply?
  • Are there native connectors for our reporting tools, and do they need a higher plan?
  • If we leave, can we export the same data, including answer history and citations, in a machine-readable format?

You're done when the vendor points to the export or API entitlement on your quote, shows you real rows or fields, and tells you whether raw answers and history are part of it.

It's also worth knowing what you can get for free from the platforms themselves, so you can judge what a paid tool adds. Google's Search Console has a generative AI performance report that reports impressions for supported Google Search generative AI features, with page, country, and device views. Bing Webmaster Tools has an AI Performance report that shows visible citation activity, with pages, grounding queries, and CSV and Excel exports. Bing says its data is an aggregated sample rather than a complete log, so it's best for trends. Google Analytics also has an AI Assistant default channel for traffic from assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Copilot. None of these is a cross-engine, prompt-level tracker, but they're a good baseline to compare against.

Common mistake: Treating an impression, a referral visit, a mention, a citation, and a click as the same event. They're different units, and a native report, a traffic channel, and a visibility platform each count a different one.

On our side, AI Visibility gives you prompt-level answer history, cited sources and pages, platform breakdowns, and a competitor leaderboard. The REST API is read-only with scoped keys, at 120 requests per minute per workspace, and reads don't spend credits. The MCP server has 23 read-only tools, and webhooks send signed notifications. None of these publish content. If reporting is a big part of your decision, the guides to custom reporting through an AEO platform API and what an AEO reporting dashboard should show and where brand monitoring data lives can help you decide what to ask for.

A DeepSmith prompt detail view showing the full ChatGPT answer to a tracked buyer question, with the brand named, the cited sources listed beneath it, and the mention rate, citation rate, and position recorded for that prompt (demo data).

Step 6: Check what happens after the report

Some tools stop at the chart. Others connect what they find to the work that comes next. Neither is wrong, but you should know which one you're buying, because a marketing lead usually needs to turn findings into content, not just read them.

Ask these:

  • Can we see which of our pages are cited and which prompts drive those citations?
  • Can we see which competitor pages are cited for the prompts we care about?
  • Does the product link visibility data to content ideas or a publishing workflow, and what's automated versus what still needs a person?
  • Does it support several brands or workspaces, roles, and our CMS or BI tools?

You're done when the vendor walks you from one visibility result to the next task in your process, and is clear about which features are included and which are priced separately.

DeepSmith is built for teams that want that handoff in one place. Content Map compares your site and competitor sites by topic, Opportunity Agents return content ideas with the data point that justifies each one, and Content Studio takes ideas through New Ideas, Planned Content, and Produced Content, with publishing to WordPress, Webflow, Strapi, Sanity, or Contentful. Deep IQ keeps your brand context so the output matches. If you only need monitoring, a standalone tracker may be enough, and the market map of AEO tools sorted by capability shows where each type fits, and the roundup of top AEO tools to track citations compares specific products.

Step 7: Hand security and privacy questions to the right people

Badges on a website don't answer procurement's questions. Give your security and legal reviewers specific things to ask, and request the documents that apply to the plan and the legal entity you'd contract with.

Ask these:

  • Which legal entity contracts with us, and which data processing agreement applies?
  • Where is customer data hosted, who are the subprocessors, and how are changes announced?
  • Can our prompts, answers, or other data be used to evaluate, develop, or train models, and what opt-outs exist?
  • How long is production data and backup data kept after termination, and when is it deleted?
  • Which certifications and reports can procurement review, and what do they cover?
  • What access controls, sign-in options, and incident notification commitments are documented?

You're done when you have the applicable DPA and security documents in hand, the contracting entity and subprocessors are named, and the data-use and deletion questions are answered in writing.

Read the documents themselves, because vendors differ. Peec AI's DPA, for example, names EU hosting locations and a U.S.-operated authentication component, asks for advance notice of most subprocessor changes, and says customer data may be used as the agreement permits to evaluate, develop, and train the models behind its service. Its trust materials list GDPR and SOC 2 Type II. That describes Peec only, and you shouldn't assume the next vendor works the same way. DeepSmith is SOC 2, GDPR, and ISO certified, and as with any vendor you should ask for the paperwork and read the clauses that matter to you.

Common mistake: Accepting a certification badge as the whole answer to where your data goes, how it's used, and when it's deleted. Ask for the document and the specific clause.

Step 8: Price your real usage and read the exit terms

Headline prices are hard to compare because a "prompt" can mean very different things. Take your own plan, with the prompt count, engine mix, countries, check frequency, projects, and seats you'd use, and ask each vendor to turn it into a monthly number. Then read the renewal and cancellation terms before you choose monthly or annual billing.

Ask these:

  • What is the billed unit, and how many runs would our planned prompt, engine, country, and schedule combination use?
  • What happens when we reach the limit: overage pricing, a hard stop, or an alert?
  • Which capabilities need a higher plan, an add-on, or a custom contract?
  • Does the discount require annual prepayment? When does the plan auto-renew, and how much notice is needed to cancel?
  • Are prepaid fees refundable, and can we lower the plan during the term?
  • After cancellation, how long can we download our data, in what formats, and when is it deleted from production and from backups?
  • Can the price change at renewal, and which document wins if the order form and the online terms disagree?

You're done when the written quote spells out the quota and overage model, the contract states how renewal and cancellation work, and the vendor confirms an export window, the formats, and a deletion schedule.

The OtterlyAI pricing page shows why units matter. It defines one credit as one prompt checked once on one engine, but says Claude uses three credits per answer while the other engines use one. Its plans run from a Lite plan at 29 euros a month with 16 prompts to a Premium plan at 489 euros a month with 403 prompts, and the cards show four of seven engines even though the page also says every plan can track every engine. Those are questions to ask, and the answers change what the real cost is. Its terms, updated October 2026, say self-service customers can download their data for 30 days after termination. Peec AI's published plans start at $95 a month for 50 prompts and three chosen models, with an extra-model add-on on top, and its terms vary by region, so the notice period and export window depend on which entity you sign with. These are details as reviewed in November 2026, so check current pricing before you rely on them.

For DeepSmith, Pro is $99 a month ($80 billed annually), Grow is $199 ($160), and Scale is $399 ($299), with custom Enterprise pricing. There's a 7-day free trial and no long-term contracts or cancellation fees. For a wider look at what else can raise the bill, see the guide to hidden costs in AI visibility software.

Common mistake: Comparing monthly prices when one plan's "prompt" means a different number of engine runs, regions, or recurring checks. Price your usage pattern, not the label.

Turn your answers into a 100-point scorecard

Once you've asked the questions, you need a way to compare what you heard, and that's the practical core of how to choose AI visibility provider options. Here's a simple AI visibility tool checklist you can copy into a spreadsheet. It's a decision aid we're proposing, not an industry benchmark or a rating of any vendor, so treat the weights as a starting point and change them to match your priorities.

CategoryPointsWhat full credit looks like
Engine and surface fit20Exact engines and experiences listed, your markets and languages covered, and included versus add-on coverage is clear.
Collection and quota clarity15Method, schedule, location, quota unit, and overage behavior explained in writing.
Metric definitions and reporting20Mention, citation, visibility, share-of-voice, and sentiment defined, with usable breakdowns by prompt, engine, competitor, and date.
Answer-level evidence and export15You can open answer history and cited pages, and export useful detail in the formats you need.
Workflow and integration fit10The CMS, BI, API, workspace, or workflow features you need are included or clearly priced.
Security and data handling10DPA, subprocessors, hosting, model-use, incident, retention, and deletion terms are available and acceptable.
Price and contract exit10Total usage cost, renewal, cancellation, refund, export window, and deletion terms are clear in the contract.
Total100

Score each line 0, half, or full. Give zero if the answer is missing or unsupported, half if it's partial or needs a workaround you'd pay extra for, and full if it's clear, shown in the vendor's normal interface, and documented for the plan you were quoted. Score the evidence you were shown, not how polished the presentation was.

Pro tip: Keep a separate list of must-haves, such as a specific engine, a region, a data export, or a security requirement. A vendor with a high total that misses one of those should still be out. Set your own cutoffs too, since no score is an established market standard. If this AI visibility tool checklist turns up a close call, the next move is a short trial, which is covered in the 14-day proof of concept guide. And if a vendor's claims seem too good, the list of claims to question before you buy is a useful second read.

What to do next

Take your scorecard and your must-have list into the next demo, and send the same questions to every vendor in writing so you can compare their answers side by side. When you evaluate AI visibility tool options this way, the quote and the contract end up matching what was shown on the call. Then hand the security and exit-term answers to procurement before anyone signs. If you'd like to see how DeepSmith answers these questions, you can start a 7-day free trial and check it against your own scorecard.

Frequently asked questions

What questions should I ask before buying an AI visibility tool?

Ask which exact engines and surfaces your plan covers, where and how often prompts run, and what a prompt, credit, or run costs. Ask how mentions, citations, and share of voice are defined, whether you can open and export the answers and cited pages, and which integrations and security terms apply. Finish with the renewal, cancellation, export, and deletion terms.

Are AI citations the same as traffic or clicks?

No. A citation means your content was shown as a source in an AI answer. It doesn't tell you that anyone clicked, visited, or engaged with it.

How should I compare prompt limits between tools?

Compare the unit behind the limit. Find out whether one prompt is checked once per engine, location, and schedule, whether several engines use separate credits, and whether any engine costs more. Then work out how many recurring runs your own coverage would need.

Does an AI visibility dashboard show every answer users get?

You shouldn't assume so. Some tools run prompts on a recurring schedule, and some native reports are aggregated samples. Ask what the tool collects, what context it captures, how long it keeps history, and whether the dashboard is a full log or a sample.