DeepSmith

Nov 26 · AEO & AI Visibility

19 min read

How GEO Tools Score Content: What Is Inside an AI Readiness Score

Avinash Saurabh
Avinash Saurabh · CO-Founder & CEO
White cover line reading How GEO Tools Score Content over gray linework of a score dial, stacked cards and small bar charts on a charcoal background.

An AI readiness score is a rating that a tool gives your content based on its own list of criteria for being easy to find, understand, trust and reuse in AI search. A GEO content score works the same way, and the tool decides what goes into it. If you've run a page through one of these tools and got back a number like 72, it helps to know what that number is made of before you decide what to do about it. This guide walks through the signals tools look at, how they turn those signals into one number, why two tools can give the same page very different results, and how much weight the score deserves.

One thing to keep in mind from the start. The score describes how your content fits one vendor's rubric. It isn't a grade issued by ChatGPT, Gemini or Google, and it isn't a forecast that your page will be cited.

What is an AI readiness score?

An AI readiness score is a vendor-defined rating of how well a piece of content meets that tool's criteria for being accessible, understandable, well supported and easy to reuse in AI search. Here, "readiness" is about your content and its suitability for AI answers. It has nothing to do with how ready your company is to adopt AI.

The label covers a few different things, and it's worth knowing which one a tool means:

  • Content readiness looks at the copy itself: clear answers, evidence, and sections that make sense on their own.
  • Technical readiness looks at whether a page can be found, fetched, rendered and read by a crawler.
  • Site or brand readiness adds information about identity, trust and presence outside your own site.
  • Hybrid readiness mixes some or all of the above, and sometimes includes things the tool has observed in real AI answers.

These four groups are a handy way to sort what you see, though they aren't an industry standard.

Readiness is not the same as visibility or citations

A readiness score and an observed citation are different kinds of evidence. A quick way to keep them apart:

MeasurementWhat it tells youWhat it doesn't tell you
Content-readiness assessmentHow the copy fits a tool's editorial or structural criteriaThat an engine chose the page
Technical eligibility checkWhether access, rendering or indexing conditions are metThat the content will show up in an answer
Observed brand mentionYour brand appeared in a collected AI responseThat your website was cited
Observed page citationA collected response pointed to your page as a sourceThat it will happen again for other prompts or next week
Hybrid scoreA vendor's blend of several inputsA pure measure of writing quality, or one you can compare across tools

That last row matters more than it looks. It would be easy to assume every readiness score is a pre-publication check on the writing. Juma's published rubric, for example, includes off-site search results and observed Google AI Overview references in one of its components. So some scores are partly about what has already happened in the wild.

How a GEO score differs from an SEO score

There's a lot of overlap, because search engines still need pages that can be found, read and understood. Frase's documentation separates on-page SEO scoring from GEO scoring, which asks whether AI systems can pull out and reference the information. If you're curious about the wider category, what a GEO tool is covers the main kinds of software.

What signals go into a GEO content score?

Tools score a mix of structure, direct answers, evidence, entity clarity, readability, trust, technical access, structured data and freshness. No tool covers all of these in the same way, and the grouping below is a summary of the documentation from three vendors, not a formula that everyone shares or a ranking of what matters most.

Structure and organization

Structure checks look at headings, heading order, paragraphs, lists, tables, summary blocks and where one section ends and the next begins. Frase includes structured information among its GEO categories and describes a Structure dimension that favors consistent headings, logical flow and lists where they fit. OtterlyAI looks at a Summary Block, Section Integrity and Modular Content Enhancements. Juma splits structure into its own dimension and counts things like the number of H1s, H2 and H3 coverage, skipped heading levels, lists, tables, FAQ sections and emphasis markup.

A page can have plenty of headings and still not answer anything under them. Structure is about how the page is organized, while extractability is about what a single passage says. A detector finding a table or an FAQ also doesn't make it useful, so skip a table if the information doesn't call for one.

Direct answers and extractability

This group asks whether a section states its answer outright and whether that answer still makes sense when it's lifted out of the page. Frase names Direct answer potential and Question coverage. OtterlyAI checks that each section has a clear purpose, finishes its thought and can stand on its own. Juma looks for definitions of key terms, a summary near the top, self-contained openings and where the answer is placed.

Juma's rubric specifically rewards openings of 40 to 60 words under H2 headings. That's one vendor's habit, and no engine has documented it as a passage length requirement. Short also doesn't mean stripped of context. An answer sometimes needs a named subject, a scope, a unit or a condition to stay accurate once it's pulled out of its paragraph.

Here's a simple example. A section headed "What does the service include?" can hold a bullet list and still only refer to "the items above." A tool can see the structure, but an engine pulling out that one section can't tell what it's about.

Evidence and source support

Evidence checks look for named sources, outbound references, data-backed statements, author information, original data and claims with nothing behind them. Frase's Authority guidance recommends credible sources and data-backed statements and steers away from vague, unsupported ones, and its content-score documentation lists Citation worthiness. Juma's Content Authority component covers named authors, original data, authority links, inline attributions and credentials, and takes points off for unsupported superlatives. OtterlyAI includes External Link Suggestions.

The limit here is a big one. A tool can detect a link, a number or a byline, and that isn't the same as checking that the claim is true. None of the scoring pages reviewed show real fact-checking. A checker might give "research shows this works" and a sentence naming a study and its limits a similar mark if each has a link, so a person still has to judge the quality.

Entity clarity and consistent terms

An entity is the specific person, company, product or place your content is about. Entity checks look at whether names stay consistent, terms are defined, acronyms are introduced and the identity information matches across the visible text and the structured data. OtterlyAI scores Acronyms and Terminology, including clear introductions and consistent use. Juma's Entity Consistency component compares Organization schema names, sameAs identity links, brand names in structured data against page metadata, spelling drift, body mentions and Wikipedia or Wikidata references. Bing's guidelines recommend clear, consistent names for people, organizations, products and locations, and tell publishers to avoid ambiguous references.

Entity clarity isn't the same as repeating a keyword. Say a fictional company, Harbor Analytics, writes "It supports the platform." Pulled out of the page, nobody knows who "it" is. A sentence that names Harbor Analytics and the platform can be understood by itself.

Readability and trust

Readability checks look at sentence structure, flow, repetition, jargon, vague language and specificity. OtterlyAI is the most detailed here, with separate categories such as Semantic Repetition, Paragraph Cohesion and Specificity, and Frase also names Readability. Clear writing should still keep the honest qualifications, so don't let a nudge to sound more assertive turn an uncertain point into a certain one.

Trust checks vary more. Google encourages clear sourcing and accurate author information where readers would expect it. Juma's On-Page Trust component goes further and looks for named customers, third-party review ratings, certifications and customer counts. That means a rubric may be partly grading how a business presents itself, and a missing customer logo isn't automatically a flaw in an educational blog post. Never add credentials or review claims you can't support just to lift a score.

Technical access and rendering

Technical checks can cover crawler permissions, response metadata, server-rendered content, canonical signals, HTTPS and language attributes. A content editor that works on pasted text can't see how the finished page behaves, so checking a draft and inspecting a live page are different jobs. A technical block can matter more than several small copy suggestions, even when the total hides it.

Structured data

Structured data is machine-readable information about your content. A score may reward valid markup, required fields and agreement with the page. Juma's rubric checks JSON-LD and types such as Organization, Article, FAQPage, HowTo and Product.

Google says no special schema is needed for AI Overviews or AI Mode, and both Google and Bing say markup has to match what's visible on the page. Bing adds that structured data doesn't guarantee visibility or grounding traffic. So adding more schema types won't automatically make content more ready, and you shouldn't add markup that doesn't fit the page for the sake of points. If you want the evidence on this one, whether schema markup improves AI citations is looked at in its own guide.

Freshness and outside presence

Juma gives separate weight to Freshness (publication and modified dates) and Brand Presence (off-site search results and Google AI Overview references). These aren't writing quality signals, which is one reason two tools can disagree about copy they both read. A recent date doesn't prove the information was updated.

How do checks become a number?

Most scoring follows the same general path, which is a useful way to picture geo optimization tool scoring even though vendors build it in their own ways. The tool collects the content and metadata, runs individual checks or judgments, rolls those into category scores, combines the categories, and shows you a total with explanations. Vendors don't all follow these steps in this order.

Some checks are simple to state, such as whether a heading exists, a JSON-LD block parses or a publication date is visible. Others need a judgment about meaning, such as whether a section stands alone or a source carries real authority. The Frase and OtterlyAI pages don't say which model or process sits behind those judgments, so it would be a guess to say a language model does the scoring.

Combining categories is a design choice

The final number can depend on which categories are included, how each check is defined, how checks add up inside a category, the weight on each category, caps on sub-scores, rounding, any override for serious failures, and whether outside observations are mixed in. A vendor listing its categories doesn't mean they count equally. Frase and OtterlyAI don't publish weights or formulas in the pages reviewed.

One published example, worked through

Juma publishes its weights, which makes it a good example. Under methodology version 3.0, updated 14 May 2026, the ten dimensions are weighted like this:

DimensionWeight
AI Crawler Access8%
Citability (Structure)8%
Extractability18%
Schema Markup13%
Content Authority14%
On-Page Trust13%
Technical SEO8%
Brand Presence (SERP)5%
Freshness5%
Entity Consistency8%
Total100%

Each dimension gets a sub-score from 0 to 100. The methodology describes the overall result as a weighted average rounded to the nearest whole number, and several sections say sub-scores are capped at 100 before their weight is applied. Written out, the overall score is the sum of each category score multiplied by its weight, rounded, with 18% used as 0.18 and so on.

That makes it possible to do some arithmetic. If everything else stays the same, a 10-point rise in Extractability adds 1.8 points to the unrounded average, because 10 times 0.18 is 1.8. A 10-point rise in Entity Consistency adds 0.8 points, because 10 times 0.08 is 0.8. What you see on screen depends on rounding. This is only math on a published formula. It shows what a weight does, and it doesn't say which edit is better for your readers or which signal an engine cares about more.

There's a gap in the formula too. Juma also says crawler access works as a gate, and that a full block effectively zeroes out everything else. The methodology doesn't give the exact override or a worked example that fits it together with the weighted average. So the weighted average is the published rule, with a stated gate whose details aren't disclosed, and you can't rebuild the whole calculation from the weights alone.

This is why the breakdown tends to be more useful than the headline. A total can hide whether the weak spot is missing evidence, a rendering problem or a missing format element.

Why do tools score the same content differently?

Tools disagree because they define readiness in different ways, and not because one shared engine grade is being measured wrongly. Here's where the differences come from.

Scope. A draft-level score might look at answers and prose. A published-page audit might also look at HTML, crawler access, metadata and structured data. A hybrid score might include off-site brand presence.

Definitions. Structure can mean heading hierarchy in one rubric and self-contained sections in another. Authority might mean source links, authorship, business proof, or all of those at once.

Weights. An 18% Extractability component moves the total differently from an 8% structure component, and a vendor that doesn't publish weights can't be assumed to do either.

Thresholds and presentation. OtterlyAI's readiness documentation calls anything above 51% good and recommends 60% to 80% as optimal. Juma's bands are Excellent at 80 to 100, Good at 60 to 79, Needs Work at 40 to 59 and Critical at 0 to 39. Those numbers describe different rubrics, so they shouldn't be set on one grading scale. Frase's own documentation also advises against chasing perfect 100s.

Versions. Juma versions its methodology, and Frase's public documents describe different categories in different places. A help article last updated 6 January 2026 describes a GEO score built on Authority, Readability and Structure, while Content Scores Explained lists Direct answer potential, Citation worthiness, Structured information and Question coverage. The sources don't say whether these are different versions or levels of explanation, so each belongs to its own document. A changed score also shouldn't be put down to better content unless the basis for assessment is the same.

What do AI search engines actually document?

The engines publish ordinary search foundations and guidance, and none of them publishes a readiness grade. It helps to read their statements next to a vendor's rubric, so you can tell what's an engine's own guidance and what's a vendor's heuristic.

Google. Its AI Features and Your Website documentation, last updated 10 December 2025, says existing SEO best practices still apply to AI Overviews and AI Mode. A page has to be indexed and eligible to show in Google Search with a snippet to be eligible as a supporting link. There are no additional technical requirements, important content should be available as text, and structured data should match the visible text. Publishers don't need AI text files or special schema, and meeting the requirements doesn't guarantee crawling, indexing or serving. Google's AI features guidance also notes that these features may run several related searches, which a page-level rubric can't capture.

Bing. Its Webmaster Guidelines tie AI grounding to the same foundations used for discovery, indexing and ranking. They recommend content that can be understood without outside context, explicit facts and definitions, clear and consistent names for people, organizations, products and locations, and logical headings. They also say GEO doesn't guarantee grounding or citations. These back up clarity and entity definition as real concerns without putting a number on them.

OpenAI. OpenAI documents separate agents for separate purposes. OAI-SearchBot surfaces sites in ChatGPT search results, GPTBot crawls material that may be used for training, and ChatGPT-User supports actions a person starts. OpenAI's crawler overview says search and training permissions are independent. This matters for scoring, because Juma's rubric rewards access for several agents, including GPTBot and ChatGPT-User, and rewards experimental AI text files. Those are choices in its rubric, and they aren't universal requirements for ChatGPT search visibility.

E-E-A-T. Google says E-E-A-T isn't a specific ranking factor. Its systems use a mix of factors linked to experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness, with trust the most important. Quality raters don't control rankings and their data isn't used directly in ranking. So a tool's EEAT score is that vendor's view of related qualities, and it isn't a readout of any public Google grade. The same ideas show up in Google's people-first content guidance, which is worth reading next to any tool's trust checks. We also have a closer look at whether E-E-A-T is a ranking factor if you want the evidence in full.

Where the research fits

The 2024 paper GEO: Generative Engine Optimization, presented at KDD 2024, tested methods on GPT-3.5-turbo and Perplexity and found they could raise visibility by up to 40%, with adding sources, quotations and statistics among the best performers. Those were relative changes in the study's own visibility measures. They don't translate into a 40-point score gain, a 40% chance of citation or proof that any vendor's weights are right.

How much weight should you give the score?

Give the number enough weight to organize your questions, and not enough to make the decision for you or to serve as an outcome measure. A readiness score is useful for summarizing what a defined rubric found, pointing you to unclear answers, unsupported claims, inconsistent terms or technical obstacles, and discussing recurring problems across content that was assessed the same way.

It's less helpful when the category explanations, the scope or the calculation are hidden. A few habits make it easier to use well:

  • Read the diagnosis along with the total. A specific unsupported claim is something you can fix. An unexplained 68 isn't.
  • Compare like with like. Don't treat numbers from different vendors as interchangeable. Even inside one tool, a change in method or scope can change what a number means.
  • Separate severity from point value. A crawler block or a factual error can matter more than several small formatting suggestions, even when the points say otherwise.
  • Protect accuracy. Keep the necessary uncertainty, skip FAQs that don't fit, don't invent business proof and don't add schema to satisfy a detector.
  • Don't make 100 the goal. The aim is a page that's accurate, clear, well supported and reachable.
  • Keep what was observed separate from what was assessed. Real brand mentions and page citations should be reported as observed responses, with the platform, the prompts and the time period, and a readiness number shouldn't stand in for them. If you want to know how steady those observations are from day to day, how AI visibility scores hold up day to day is a good next read.

A useful readiness score makes its reasoning visible. Treat the total as a summary of that assessment, and judge the content by the accuracy, clarity, evidence and accessibility behind it. Whether a tool only measures or also helps you fix what it finds is a separate question, covered in tracking-only versus tracking-plus-content GEO tools. If you want to see how audit tools in this area differ, best AEO audit tools lists them. When you're ready to look at one of your own pages, our guide to auditing content for AI citations walks through how to do it.

Frequently asked questions

How do GEO tools score content for AI readiness?

They assess criteria that are specific to each tool, such as explicit answers, coherent structure, supporting evidence, consistent terms and technical accessibility, and then produce category scores or a combined rating. Some broader assessments also include brand and off-site signals.

What is a good AI readiness score?

There's no shared target across tools. OtterlyAI recommends 60% to 80% as optimal, while Juma labels 80 to 100 as Excellent under a different rubric. Read the number against its own methodology and not a universal threshold.

Is an AI readiness score the same as an SEO score?

No. A GEO score usually puts more emphasis on how clearly information can be understood and reused in AI answers, while an SEO score may focus on on-page optimization or coverage of topics found on competing pages. The publishing and technical foundations underneath overlap a lot.

Does a higher readiness score mean the page will be cited?

No. The score describes how the page meets a particular tool's criteria. Actual citations have to be observed separately, and both Google and Bing say that eligibility or optimization doesn't guarantee inclusion.